TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (The News Service of Florida) — The state-backed Citizens Property Insurance Corp. appears likely to delay a proposed rate filing, as leaders worry about a rapidly increasing number of policies and trouble in the private insurance market.
The Citizens Board of Governors was expected Wednesday to take up a proposal that called for an average rate increase of 3.7 percent for residential policies. But during a committee meeting Tuesday, Citizens Chairman Carlos Beruff pushed to delay a rate decision to give time for staff members to go on a “fact-finding mission” with state regulators on rate-related issues.
At Beruff’s urging, the Citizens Actuarial and Underwriting Committee approved a recommendation that the board wait until Jan. 26 to make a rate decision after the talks with regulators. Ultimately, the state Office of Insurance Regulation must sign off on any rate changes.
While Citizens was designed as an insurer of last resort, it has seen large increases recently in policies, with President and CEO Barry Gilway saying Citizens is adding about 10,000 policies a month. Citizens had about 427,000 policies in 2018, a number that is projected to increase to 532,135 this year and 630,257 next year, according to a report set to go before the board Wednesday.
Citizens leaders want to slow the growth, with Beruff and others saying that rates need to be higher to be more actuarially sound. Beruff said Citizens’ rates often are cheaper than rates charged by private insurers.
“We’re (not) the insurer of last resort. We’re the insurer of first resort and growing rapidly disproprotionately to the market,” Beruff said. “So we have some issues that can’t continue.”
Beruff also said he is concerned that if Florida would get hit with a massive hurricane, part of the costs of covering Citizens’ claims could fall on insurance policyholders who are not Citizens customers. That is because of a system of what are known as “assessments” that provide a backstop for Citizens.
“At the end of the day, it all falls on the shoulders of the Florida taxpayers, which is exactly what I never want to be a part of,” Beruff said.
The issues raised by Beruff have long surrounded Citizens, which worked for years to shed policies before the recent increases. But lawmakers and regulators also have faced heavy pressure from consumers to hold down rates as residents in some areas complained they could not find affordable private coverage.
One factor that has held down Citizens’ rates, for example, was a decision by lawmakers to prevent individual policyholders from seeing rate increases of more than 10 percent a year.
Another piece in the discussion is that Gilway said private property insurers are struggling financially.
“We have a situation in the overall marketplace where the overall industry profitability has dropped dramatically. … This is creating a situation within the marketplace where private carriers simply are not responding, they don’t have the capacity to respond in the marketplace,” Gilway said. “It’s also exacerbating the situation because, if a company takes action against a customer and non-renews that customer, that customer would go to the private market and likely be faced with a 20, 30 and even 40 percent rate increase. Where as if they come to Citizens, they would actually be getting a substantial decrease. So it puts us in an untenable situation from a competitive standpoint.”