Jury renders not guilty verdict in 2017 fatal shooting


JACKSON COUNTY, Fla. (WMBB) — A Marianna man has been inside the Jackson County Correctional Facility since 2017. On Thursday, he became a free man after a jury found him not guilty in a fatal shooting.

Ja’Drian Gilbert was previously accused of shooting and killing Gregory Barnett Jr. on March 18, at a home on Old Cottondale Road in Marianna.

According to the police report by the Marianna Police, Gilbert got into an altercation with Michael James and the victim, Barnett before shots were fired.

After more than two years, Gilbert faced a jury.

During the three day trial, the jury was presented evidence, heard testimonies from witnesses, including Gilbert and on Thursday, heard from the attorneys one last time.

During closing arguments, Assistant State Attorney Shalla Jefcoat stated Gilbert was known to lie when it benefited him, saying Gilbert changed his story of what happened multiple times.

“First it was ‘I’ve never had a problem with these guys. I don’t know why they’re approaching me.’ That’s his first statement and now two and half years later, it’s ‘well they were robbing me,” said Jefcoat.

Ja’Drian Gilbert inside the courtroom on Thursday

Gilbert’s attorney, Roderick Vereen admitted his client did lie to officers in his initial interview in fear of being charged with possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.

The defense’s argument throughout the trial was Gilbert was acting in self-defense on that day.

He says Gilbert got into a physical altercation with James before seeing Barnett pull out a gun.

“And guess what? He drops it and at that point, Mr. Gilbert sees it and he reaches for his and what happens? Mr. Barnett doesn’t back away from the gun, throw his hands up. Dr. Radtke says he’s in a bent over position at the time he’s shot. He (Gilbert) had to react and his reaction was to fire.”

Doctor Jay Radtke is the Chief Medical Examiner for the 14th Judicial Circuit and testified in the trial.

After investigation, no weapon was found at the crime scene.

Jefcoat argued if James or Barnett had a firearm, things might’ve happened differently.

“If Gregory Barnett and or Michael James had a gun, then why did Michael James have to run off at the sound of a gunshot? Why didn’t he fire his own weapon? Why didn’t he pick up Gregory Barnett’s gun and use that to try and shoot the defendant? Because they didn’t exist,” Jefcoat said.

The state charged Gilbert with second-degree murder, arguing even if he didn’t have intention to hurt anyone, Gilbert still took the life Barnett.

“I submit to you that firing a gun at a person, even if you didn’t intend to cause death, you don’t care if it does,” Jefcoat said.

Vereen argued in his final words to the jury, the state didn’t prove the charges against Gilbert.

The jury deliberated for about three hours before bringing back a verdict of not guilty.

Gilbert had a previous charge of introduction of contraband into jail but he entered a no contest plea on Thursday as well and sentenced.

However, Gilbert was granted time served for the time waiting in jail for the second-degree murder trial.

Gilbert will be now discharged from the Jackson County Correctional Facility.

Copyright 2020 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Latest Local News Video

Tracking the Tropics June 3: Tropical Storm Cristobal moving inland over Mexico

Thumbnail for the video titled "Tracking the Tropics June 3: Tropical Storm Cristobal moving inland over Mexico"

13NOW | Gov. DeSantis State Update 03JUN2020

Thumbnail for the video titled "13NOW | Gov. DeSantis State Update 03JUN2020"

Boys & Girls Club providing swim lessons

Thumbnail for the video titled "Boys & Girls Club providing swim lessons"

3rd Grade Class

Thumbnail for the video titled "3rd Grade Class"

COVID-19 has potential to spread during protests, marches, health experts warn

Thumbnail for the video titled "COVID-19 has potential to spread during protests, marches, health experts warn"

First Baptist Church holds socially distanced graduation for preschoolers

Thumbnail for the video titled "First Baptist Church holds socially distanced graduation for preschoolers"
More Local News